Police in the Crisis of Democracy
The role of police in U.S. democracy is at a dangerous crossroads. Although George Floyd’s murder in the summer of 2020 sparked a movement that put police reform at the top of the national conversation, the national appetite for police reform has quickly stalled with public perceptions of rising crime levels and tough -on-crime rhetoric and policies. Moreover, with Trump’s presidential re -election in November 2024, we are experiencing a realignment and coalescence of federal and state right -wing populist power that is animating new laws and policies affecting state and local law enforcement.
This Article illuminates how recent anti -democratic movement in U.S. policing at the state and local levels — particularly in the past five or so years — has coincided with broader anti -democratic currents in U.S. society. It examines and presents an organizing framework for understanding recent anti-democratic movement in state and local policing along two dimensions: illiberalism and authoritarianism. The analysis examines three recent illiberal policing developments that, as explained, violate or undermine the dignity, liberty, and autonomy of vulnerable groups and dissenters in society: (1) expanding state and local police involvement in immigration enforcement; (2) disproportionate, aggressive, and militarized police responses to public protests and demonstrations; and (3) growing influence of far -right and anti - government extremism in state and local law enforcement. It then examines five recent authoritarian developments that, as explained, undermine police accountability: (1) politically-targeted state and federal efforts to control local policing; (2) restricting or eliminating civilian police oversight; (3) creating “buffer zones” for law enforcement officers; (4) abandoning federal oversight of state and local law enforcement agencies; and (5) rolling back of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives in law enforcement.
This Article argues that recent anti -democratic movement in state and local policing is illegitimate and harmful to individuals, marginalized groups, and liberal democracy in its own right. These developments also undermine public safety — what many argue should be the primary goal of policing. At most risk for harm are civilians who challenge our increasingly dominant right -wing populist order through dissent and individuals who belong to marginalized communities that are defined as “other” by populist powerholders and their constituents — including noncitizens, communities of color, and LGBTQ+ communities. In some instances, the safety of law enforcement is also put at risk.
The analysis in this Article prompts meaningful questions about what roles scholars, courts, lawmaking bodies, law enforcement leaders, and the public might have to address recent anti -democratic movement in U.S. policing in a time of unprecedented attacks on democratic norms and institutions in the United States. Although many questions remain about how to solve these complex problems, this Article presses the key point that finding solutions requires taking connections between anti -democratic currents in state and local policing and our broader democracy seriously.